Quick Update: Gold and Gold Royalty companies

Gold Royalty Companies: Early in October I stumbled across Mining Stock Monkey looking for gold miners.  I ended up taking a 4% position in a medium sized gold royalty company.  They're a better alternative to miners, as they're not affected by rising costs, like Newmont was last month.  But the big Gold Royalty companies are at nosebleed valuations.  And the small ones are bleeding cash or reliant on one or two revenue streams.  The medium sized ones that are just turning cashflow positive may be better bets.  Mining Stock Monkey also has a youtube channel where he discusses details on some smaller companies.

Gold is finally starting to get attention, even from mainstream media like CNN.  Worries me a bit as its getting too visible.  But I'll hold my 10% (paper) gold and 8% mining and royalty companies (at buy price) for the long term, not try to trade around them.  Theres a good chance gold stays rangebound for a long time, like oil in the past two years or Uranium in the past 12 months.

Physical Gold.  Luke Gromen did an interview on gold, he mentioned paper gold, while he thinks the ETFs' units are backed by gold reserves, but the risk is with the LME ("where historically a lot of the GLD gold was").  Unallocated gold in LME.  By "paper gold" he means "unallocated gold derivatives centred in London".  Still trying to figure out what he means.  But I'm thinking of converting my gold ETFs to physical.  For most of the black swans I can think of:

• Taiwan war
• US civil war
• US govt devalues USD 10% in a day

...gold is an insurance, and the only insurance.  If this shit actually happens, I'd be spending some uncomfortable nights wondering if my gold ETF positions were actually worth anything.

Quick Update and thoughts on oil and gold.

My portfolio surged past SGD 1.2m last week, everything has been going right the past month.  The cherry on top was a the oil price shooting up due to fears of Israel attacking Iran's oil infrastructure.

I can't see any effect if Iran's oil export facilities are bombed.  Iran only produces 3.7m bpd, half of which is exported - say under 2m.  The Americans can release 1m bpd from their SPR for a month or two.  Last year Saudi Arabia voluntarily cut 1m bpd, and OPEC+ an additional 1m.  The world can make up for it.

Iran may retaliate against Saudi Arabia's oil facilities, that would cause a large oil increase.  And a long lasting one.  Don't think it'll happen, but its a small possibility.

I still expect oil to stay around $70-90 for a while, until reserves go down.  Politics can drive it higher (middle east war) or lower (Trump peace deal with Saudis).

My portfolio is now heavily weighted to oil.  Luke Gromen (33:52) suggests that gold will replace US bonds as a reserve store-of-value.  Gold is the 'release valve' in the world's search for a new reserve currency. Governments would prefer gold to go up instead of oil - as oil is inflationary, even though they don't control it....they could affect it to try to increase production and stop oil rising too much.

In this scenario, I think gold miners skyrocket, while oil producers do ok (as oil hovers in between $70-90).  Might be worthwhile buying more gold miners.  They will go up unless:

• there's a non-inflationary recession (interest rates and gold goes down), or
• oil surges (diesel is a large cost of mining).

So its a good hedge to oil producers, and will probably go up anyway.

Interesting Links

Commodities.  Supply/demand projections:

• Uranium (Sept 2024).  Justin Huhn shows an updated Uranium supply model (at 16:08).  From Cantor, he thinks demand here is a little optimistic.  Does not know if they include SMRs.  Probably derived from WNA's report, this looks like their upper demand scenario.  Theres a supply response from new greenfield mines in 2029.  Justin's own modelling shows at this point in time supply may meet demand, but only for 2 years.

• Anas Alhajii's views on LNG (Aug 2024): Contrary to the market, he is bullish, thinks producers will reign-in production (eg: rolling maintenance) if prices drop.

• Brendon Beylo's Tin Primer (Dec 2023).  The "Future Tin Projects" table is interesting.

ChinaTalk (Oct 2024) : JD Vance on the Economy: He's following Michael Pettis' ideas.  Why should the dollar be a reserve currency?  The Federal Reserve could impose a tax on any foreign purchase of US assets, with the rate adjustable to balance financial inflows and outflows.  Or they could buy foreign assets (like Singapore/Switzerland).  Reducing USD's reserve status (a falling USD) would help the re-industrialisation of the US, but the cant predict the first and second order global effects.

Quick Update

Most of my portfolio is up nicely:

• Hedgeye turned bullish on China after stocks rose on stimulus news.  They project Q4 has increasing yoy Chinese growth, but it may only last a quarter.  I'm not buying due to long-term Taiwan risk.  The majority of my portfolio is commeodities, which is another way of playing China anyway.
• Commodities have kept going up since Hedgeye pivoted to quad 3.  I bought 2% silver and 2% platinum on dips.  And 1% bitcoin, which has not had a real dip.  Plus a 1% fomo buy in copper (FCX) at the highs.  Look to buy a little more bitcoin before I'm finished.   Now 110% invested.
• Hartalega jumped limit-up 30% in a day a few days after I bought it on news of increased US tariffs on China gloves.  I had not realised just how fuk'n volatile this stock was, this is the second 30% day in this year.  If I had, I may have sized it a bit smaller.  I still think its undervalued as the glove market recovers over the next 3 years.  Biggest risk is rising Ringgit.
• Oil still bearish Hedgeye trend.  Which may help Harta above.
• My "Turnarounds and Lottery Tickets" - like Purecycle Tech (good production news), and the whole Singapore OSV/rig sector going up - have done well. Still plenty of room to run.
• Gold has been slowly floating up, unnoticed, week-by-week.
• Tin has moved up and down finishing off flat.  Maybe because semis are still down.
• Uranium flat, no reaction to supply cuts from Kazatomprom.  Spot is still below the incentive price of ~ $100.

Turning Bullish. Buying more.

Last night Hedgeye became bullish on a few remaining risk-on commodities: copper and bitcoin.  Pivoting to Quad 3 (decreasing yoy gdp growth rate, increasing yoy inflation growth rate).  Free release of their daily Macro Show from before the market open:

Key points, from short term to long term:

• Copper and bitcoin turned bullish trend, following silver and softs in the last few days.
• But they were overbought (before last night's open), so I may want to wait a bit before buying.  I bought 1% silver yesterday morning, after the FOMC's "sell-the-news" correction.
• Kospi and semis not yet bullish (14:01)
• Bullish on EMs (India, Indonesia, Malaysia).
• Oil still bearish (28:28), the last major commodity holding out.  WTI's trend level (right now) is 76, if it goes above that it becomes bullish.
• No recession (24:05 and 25:53).
• Bullish on 'the market' (10:42) due to vol dropping.  Quad 3 has historically been good for the S&P 500 because its dominated by big-tech.  They're not buying the index, theres better things to buy.
• Projected US quad 3 in Q4, followed by quad 2 then quad 3 (38:52 background chart)
• Inflation (21:47) rate project to drop to 2.X% this quarter, then to increase to over 3% in 2Q25. 

How do I use Hedgeye?

• Helping to decide when to buy things.  For example, I delayed loading up on oil stocks for the past 2 months after oil went bearish on 23rd July.
• Getting out.  I got out of my high volatility and non-cashflow producing assets (eg: silver, bitcoin, a high beta copper producer) in late July to early August, as one-by-one they entered bearish trend.  After which the market did its mini-crash.
• Short term, they trade in-and-out a lot, increasing positions when something corrects and selling when it overextended.  Over a few days.  I don't, cause I'm not a good trader.

In summary:

• I want to buy commodities again: copper, silver and bitcoin.  Except oil.  Turn around and sell if they go to bearish trend.  Look to buy on dips.
• If someone gives you a crystal ball which can time the markets, you should use it.  Even if the ball is a little cloudy and keeps changing.  Be a few steps in front of the herd.

Buy commodities, except oil...unless they change trend.

Buying after Black Monday

What am I thinking?

In the short term: after the Nikkei's Black Monday I was expecting more turbulence for 1 or 2 months.  Someone who gets hit in the head with a baseball bat doesn't just get up and walk again the next day.  But the markets did recover the next day and have rebounded since.  I now think theres 60% chance the turbulence is behind us.

Medium term: Hedgeye sees slowing growth and inflation in Sept, but recovery after that.  No recession.  Their signals did get me out of my higher volatility exposure (BTC, silver, platinum) before the crash - while I choose to hold onto my lower-beta cashflow generating companies.  

Long term, the US dollar is gonna be devalued, I need to be holding stocks and commodities.  Cash is trash.

So I wanna buy stocks in the next two weeks, and commodities when Hedgeye signals them.

What am I doing?

• Bought more paper gold, now have 10%.
• Plus a few speculative positions.
• Currently buying a Malaysian stock now which got hit on Black Monday.  Not buying Japanese stocks, cause I get a headache trying to read their results.
• Am waiting to buy commodities (platinum, silver, plus copper & oil producers) when the Hedgeye trends signals change.  Maybe BTC.
• If we do get another quick crash (USD is oversold and gold/SPY overbought) I may buy gold miners.

The Malaysian stock I'm halfway through buying is Hartalega, a glove producer.  Very different from the stocks I usually buy:

• Its a cyclical and a turnaround play, as the world works off the glut of gloves stockpiled from covid.  Its now slightly profitable.
• They've been a long-term-term compounder. The type of company that can make me rich.
• They are a commodity user, their raw material (nitrile) is priced off energy.  Although I'm expecting high energy prices in years to come, I've got more than enough energy exposure.
• Full report here at Asian Century Stocks (paywalled).

The small speculative positions I added are:

• Two SGX companies rigs and OSVs.  Turnaround plays.  From Trader Ferg (paywalled).
• A Uranium company (From Unemployed Degen - paywalled).  Its risky and can go to zero.

My current positions:

I've been writing less about individual investment ideas and industries lately:

• Cause I'm busy with my day job.
• And there's a lot of excellent ideas already out there.  I used to want to find new ideas myself, which was an important part of learning.  But now I'm happy to be inspired by others (and investigate their work), or simply piggyback off it (if its detailed enough).  Substack is a game changer.
• I still think we're halfway through a decade of inflation.  There's only so many ways to say "Buy Inflation".

Need to be careful not to get stuck in my thinking.  "Inflation and Commodities" isn't a religion.  Eventually US debt gets inflated away and commodities reach unsustainable prices.  Then I start looking at "normal" companies (which use commodities as inputs and do well with low inflation).  Start learning again.

New Kitty.

Chaos and Commodities

Quick look at geopolitical events, black swans and how I'm positioned for them.

This is not to make money, but to stop getting killed in the markets.  Part of Risk Management.

The last 2 months have been crazy.

Trump vs Kamala

A Trump win probably means:

• Lower oil.  Drill baby drill.  And he is friends with the Saudis.  Michael Kao suggested he can do a security deal with MBS in exchange for lower oil prices.  (Edit: Probably requires congress approval?).  Makes sense: lower inflation and increased growth.  I think lower oil prices would lead to an economic boom for 1-2 years, then leading to rising oil prices as production comes up against hard supply constraints.

I can be less bullish on oil, and even hold companies that use oil as an input.

• Rebuild America.  Return manufacturing back to the US after decades of decline.  The USD is overvalued - partially because its a reserve currency which everyone invests their excess savings into.  JD Vance questioned its roles as a reserve currency.  A Trump victory could see a sudden, deliberate devaluation of the USD by around 10% or so (ht: Lyn Alden public newsletter).  This would lead to a spiral of other currency devaluations, with shiny yellow rocks being the only currency worth holding.

The currency devaluation(s) will happen anyway, but with Trump it can be overnight. Hold gold in place of cash.

If the Democrats win, Kamala seems to be left leaning and big government.  Her policies are price controls and handouts (ban grocery price gouging, don't allow landlords to raise rent more than 5% a year).  I think congress would need to approve new laws in order to implement this - unlikely to happen.  She is probably a continuation of Biden.  America will still get rebuilt, and the USD devalued, just slowly.  Low growth and high inflation.  Better for my energy and pipeline stocks.

Ukraine and Russia

Ukraine invaded Russia.  Probably for a morale boost, and to change perceptions of the war both at home and for the countries providing weapons.  They also now control a gas pumping station that provides half of natural gas to Europe (Hungary, Slovakia and Austria).  If I were them, I'd blow it.

It may also put them in a better bargaining position if Trump forces them to negotiate.  The current view is that Biden fully supports Ukraine, while Trump will throw them under the bus (JD Vance: "I don't really care what happens to Ukraine one way or another").  A counterpoint is that the current US policy is to support Ukraine only so they can continue fighting, but not so they can win.  Trump is a good negotiator, and he may put pressure on Russia (increasing Russian sanctions and Ukrainian weapons supplies, increasing global oil supplies), leading to a Korea-like armistice.

So long term:

• If Kamala wins, same as usual.  Ukraine may be ground down in a few years unless international support increases.
• If Trump wins, negotiations for 6-12 months.  Then a ceasefire.  How favourable to Ukraine we don't know.  Energy may drop, a lot if sanctions are lifted on Russia (enough to allow them to maintain production facilities).  Still no Russian gas piped to West Europe (you cant buy energy from someone who just burned down your neighbour's house), maybe its shipped elsewhere instead....LNG down, LNG transport up?  If its a bad deal for Ukraine, then Finland and Poland quickly build nukes.  Followed by South Korea, Japan, Taiwan.

Middle East

A rocket attack killed 12 Israeli children at the end of July.  Israel and Hezbollah may be headed for war.

This war would make Gaza look like a warm up.  Hezbollah is a lot tougher than Hamas: man-for-man their special forces are as good as Israel's.  Unlike Gaza, Lebanon has open orders allowing weapons and fighters to leak in.  Hezbollah's rockets can cause large scale damage to Israeli cities.  The land is mountainous like Afghanistan.  There might be a bigger hostage situation than in Gaza.  I'd expect the Israelis to win in around a year - they have no choice.

Neither Israel nor Lebanon have oil, so we don't really care.  Two possible black swans:

• Israel hits Iran, specifically Kharg island to stop oil revenues.
• High Lebanese civilian casualties in a year-long war cause Arab populaces to protest agains their governments.  Worst case they overthrow their governments, really bad for oil production.  70% of Lebanon's population is Muslim, evenly split between Sunni and Shia, so the Arabs might not care if non-muslims or Shia get killed.

Both cases benefit my non-middle-east energy stocks.

Myanmar Civil War

Source: ResearchGate

~10% of the worlds tin comes from Wa state, bordering China and the Shan state.  The Wa State Army is (was?) allied with the ruling Junta against the Shan. Wa is in effect a Chinese satellite state.  Its a mountainous jungle region, so I think it can maintain control.  So tin production should not be affected by the civil war.

The rebels appear to be winning the civil war: they need to prove the can capture a city.  This would be the beginning of the end.  Myanmar may end up a satellite state of China. Some links:

• Warographics (April) Rebel forces make gains, possible post-war scenarios.
• Warographics (July) Rebel forces make more gains, can't see the Junta winning.
• Peter Zeihan (August) is pessimistic and thinks the Chinese do not want to control Burma, just keep it weak and divided.

UK Riots

Riots occured in the UK over migrants, sparked by fake news.  But the causes have been simmering years (Rotterdam sex grooming gangs, two tier policing).  British have continually voted against immigration, only to get more of it.  Jailing people who post on twitter does not fix the root causes of this, just adds fuel for the next fire.  Expect more riots in the months or years ahead.  

This problem will only go away when there's a government who promises to reduce unwanted (ie: Muslim) immigration.  Lets see if anyone runs on this in next year's May election.  Edit: The next election is 2029, they are fucked.

Not sure if this affects the wider economy, or the UK banks I'm looking at.  Really widespread riots would hit the economy.  An unexpected election result (like Brexit) would hit the stock market.  But these are one-off event that may or may not happen, I can't stop investing to wait for them.  Just limit any UK exposure.  Or trade the stocks as cyclicals, don't buy and hold.

China and Taiwan

No ones know what Xi is thinking. So I give a 20% chance for an invasion of Taiwan.  Either because he gets bad (or no) advice, or he sees CCP rule ending.  Most likely it would be a full out missile strike (also against US and Japanese forces) followed by an invasion - half-measures like a Chinese blockade gives the US forces to move, decreasing the odds of a successful invasion. (And the US can also blockade China).  An invasion can only occur during April or October.

I haven't found any hedge against this.  If it happens, global GDP goes down 10%.  Stocks may be cut in half immediately.  Most commodities would be hammered, as seaborne supplies to China get disrupted.  Gold may go up, but paper gold may fall with everything else in the panic.  USD spikes.

Nothing I can do about, so not worth thinking too hard.  I have no exposure to HK/China stocks, which would go to zero.  But the rest of my portfolio would be hit.  Limit my leverage.

Conclusion

Trump may give us economic growth and lower oil prices for a while.  Ukraine ceasefire bearish for energy.  Long term, the value of money goes down.  Don't hold USD - unless China invades Taiwan.

This post is a little depressing.  Next time I'll post cat pictures or something.